NY Bagel Café franchise advertisements have been dropped from two prominent franchise advertising networks after Unhappy Franchisee provided evidence of deceptive and misleading claims.
(UnhappyFranchisee.Com) CoStar Group’s business and franchise advertising networks BizBuySell.Com and BizQuest.Com are to be being lauded for their quick response to a complaint that NY Bagel Café franchise ads on their sites were fraudulent, misleading and possibly in violation of both state and federal franchise laws.
The NY Bagel Café & Deli franchise advertisements and associated broker accounts were also in violation of the franchise portals’ terms of service.
On April 8, 2015, BizBuySell deleted 20 NY Bagel Café ads and a broker account attributed to a “Vincent Smiff, FoodBrokerInc.” The phone number for Vincent Smiff was actually registered to NY Bagel CEO Joe Smith.
BizQuest deleted 9 NY Bagel Café franchise ads and the account of a supposed entity named “Frank Willis Brokerage.” The phone number (888-550-8020) listed for Mr. Willis is the general franchise number of New York Bagel Enterprises, Inc. and Mr. Willis’ P.O. Box (PO Box 4244, New Windsor, New York) is believed to be associated with CEO Joe Smith.
NY Bagel Café Allegedly Listed Businesses For Sale That Don’t Exist
The NY Bagel Café franchise ads were positioned under the heading of “established businesses” for sale rather than general franchise opportunity ads.
Some of the ads even cited gross sales figures and inventory valuations.
However, our research indicates that no NY Bagel Cafe locations exist or ever existed in most of the locations indicated in the 30 ads currently appearing on BizBuySell and BizQuest.
The listings contained photographs of stores in other regions, some of which we’ve identified as failed franchise stores from other parts of the country. (See NY BAGEL CAFÉ Franchise: How Many Have Closed? [UPDATED])
NY Bagel Café Ads Violating State Franchise Laws?
4 of the 20 BizBuySell NY Bagel Cafe ads and 3 of the 9 BizQuest ads targeted states where franchise registration is required by law (CA, MD, VA, IL). The regulatory franchise agencies of CA, MD, VA & IL have confirmed that NY Bagel Cafe is not registered in their states and cannot legally advertise its franchise opportunity to their residents.
Some of the ads NY Bagel Café ran for unregistered (therefore illegal) franchises included:
- NY Bagel Franchise Ad 040115 Los Angeles (PDF)
- NY Bagel Franchise Ad 040115 Baltimore (PDF)
- NY Bagel Franchise Ad 040115 Fairfax VA (PDF)
- NY Bagel Franchise Ad 040115 Springfield IL (PDF)
NY Bagel Café Claim of 100% Financing Challenged
Of the many questionable claims NY Bagel Café makes in its advertising, Unhappy Franchisee is most concerned about the prominent representation that prospective franchisees need only pay the up-front franchise fee (typically $17,500 – $29,500) and the company will provide 100% financing for the remainder of the investment.
We have received complaints from franchisees who claim that NY Bagel Cafe claims to offer financing or easy access to financing until the non-refundable fee is paid, then they are on their own. When they fail to procure funding for the $100K+ investment, the company refuses to return their franchise fee. We posted the account of one franchisee who provided an email from NY Bagel Café salesman Dennis Mason (DENNIS MASON Franchise Complaints) who promised a refund if financing could not be obtained, then later refused to return her $25,000. (See NY BAGEL CAFÉ Franchise a Scam? MA Woman Says Yes)
NY Bagel Café franchise ads state:
… all monies required for the build-out, equipment, furniture & fixtures, inventory, lease & security deposits, working capital is “100% financed”. “ONLY CASH REQUIRED $17,500”. EVERYTHING NEEDED TO OPEN YOUR STORE IS 100% FINANCED OVER THE $17,500 FF [Franchise Fee].
However, the NY Bagel Café franchise website states:
Does N.Y. Bagel Cafe’ & Deli provide financing?
N.Y. Bagel Cafe’ & Deli does not provide direct financing…
We have asked NY Bagel Café CEO Joseph Smith to explain this apparent contradiction. Joe Smith stated:
[Joe Smith has not replied to our question as of yet. Please check back soon]
Nearly 90% of NY Bagel Café Franchises Opened Have Closed
Some stores the company tries to pass off as new locations are actually failed franchises that have been resold to new owners, for new fees… a process known as “churning.”
In its “10 years of proven success” NY Bagel Café has only managed to maintain 4 operational stores, yet their franchise ads claim “NY Bagel is poised to add a 1000 new restaurants in the next 10 years.”
Another outrageous advertising claim is that NY Bagel Cafe has “96% brand awareness.” The NY Bagel Cafe chain consists of only 4 local locations in 3 states (NY, NJ, LA) and does minimal local advertising. It seems implausible that this tiny chain has any brand awareness whatsoever.
Beware of NY Bagel Café Franchise Ads on Craig’s List & Elsewhere
While we are pleased with the speedy investigation and response of BizBuySell and BizQuest in deleting NY Bagel Café franchise ads and its bogus broker accounts, NY Bagel Café, its CEO Joe Smith and franchise salesman Dennis K. Mason are still running questionable ads on Craig’s List and elsewhere.
Franchise portals like Franchise Gator, Franchising.Com, FranchiseOpportunities.Com and others are promoting the NY Bagel Café franchise.
We ask all of those who are helping to promote NY Bagel Café and other franchise opportunities with disturbingly high failure rates to reconsider.
Have you had dealings (good, bad or neutral) with NY Bagel Café, CEO Joe Smith or franchise salesman Dennis Mason, please contact us in confidence at UnhappyFranchisee[at]Gmail.Com or leave a comment below.
NY Bagel Café Franchise Ad with Comments:
ARE YOU FAMILIAR WITH NY BAGEL FRANCHISE OPPORTUNITY, JOE SMITH OR DENNIS MASON?
PLEASE SHARE YOUR OPINION BELOW or Contact UnhappyFranchisee.com
TAGS: NY Bagel Cafe & Deli, NY Bagel franchise, NY Bagel Cafe franchise, NY Bagel Cafe and Deli franchise, New York Bagel Cafe, NY Bagel Cafe, New York Bagel franchise, New York Bagel Cafe, NY Bagel complaints, NY Bagel lawsuits, Joe Smith, Joseph Smith, Dennis Mason, franchise scam, franchise failure rates, bagel franchise, franchise advertising