Are THE UPS STORE Franchise Owners Cheating UPS Customers? Franchisee Lawsuit Says Yes.

The UPS Store franchise owners in Manhattan claim they were targeted, terminated and ultimately sued because they blew the whistle on unethical and fraudulent practices of other The UPS Store franchisees.

(UnhappyFranchisee.Com) The UPS Store franchisees Robert Hagan, Thomas Hagan and their related entities, represented by the law firm of Stephen J. Savva, P.C. , have filed a countersuit against The UPS Store, Inc., United Parcel Service, Inc. and United Parcel Service of America, Inc. alleging that they were retaliated against by complaining that other The UPS Store franchisees:

  • Lie about the UPS Ground delivery guarantee
  • Misleading customers about guaranteed delivery dates
  • Upselling higher-price shipping options that offer no additional benefits to customers
  • Concealing the existence of cheaper cost shipping services when requested by customers
  • Add inches to the dimensions of boxes
  • Adding weight to boxes
  • Charge customers more than the maximum allowable UPS retail rate
  • Charging customers for “accessorial” charges they did not request.

Read the Answer with Counterclaims and Third Party Complaint here:  The UPS Store Franchise Lawsuit Counterclaims

Read the press release issued by the law firm of Stephen J. Savva, P.C. below:

Law Firm Files Counterclaims Against UPS and The UPS Store, Inc. on Behalf of 11-Store Franchise Owner; Allegations Include “Massive Fraud Perpetrated Upon the Public”

On April 16, 2014, the law firm of Stephen J. Savva, P.C. filed papers in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York alleging that UPS and its affiliates presided over a fraud

perpetrated upon the public that generated millions of dollars in additional revenues for UPS, royalties for The UPS Store, Inc. and incentives for those franchisees who willfully

participated.   UPS, Inc. et al. v. Hagan, et al. (U.S. District Court, SDNY)(14-cv-1210-WHP).
New York, NY (PRWEB) April 21, 2014 — According to recently filed court documents, the two owners of a 20% market share of “The UPS Store” franchise locations in Manhattan have responded to a lawsuit filed by

The UPS Store, Inc. (“TUPSS”), United Parcel Service, Inc. and United Parcel Service of America, Inc. (collectively “UPS”) with counterclaims and a third-party complaint seeking more than $50 Million in

damages, plus punitive damages, costs, attorneys’ fees and other relief. The papers were filed on April 16, 2014 in New York Federal Court in lower Manhattan in the action entitled, The UPS Store, Inc., et al. v. Robert Hagan, et al. (S.D.N.Y., 12-cv-1200-WHP).
The federal civil action was initially commenced by UPS on February 25, 2014. According to the complaint on file, UPS seeks money damages and other relief against Robert Hagan, Thomas Hagan and each of their jointly owned corporate entities. The Hagans’ responded last week by filing court documents denying all claims and asserting counterclaims against UPS and TUPSS for breach of contract, fraud, retaliation, tortious interference, unfair trade practices and multiple violations of consumer protection laws in New York and California. The court documents also include detailed allegations of alleged unethical business practices observed at other “The UPS Store” locations in Manhattan and California between October 2013 and January 2014.
According to the court-filed counterclaims, at the heart of the Hagans’ counterclaims is an alleged November 12, 2013 meeting at TUPSS’s corporate boardroom in San Diego.

Court records state that the Hagans allege they notified senior TUPSS executives about questionable business practices they discovered while trying to improve their own business operations. According to the pleadings, the business practices allegedly reported by the Hagans involved franchisees “lying about the UPS Ground delivery guarantee”; “misleading customers about guaranteed delivery dates”; “upselling higher-price shipping options that offer no additional benefits to customers”; “concealing the existence of cheaper cost shipping services when requested by customers”; “adding inches to the dimensions of boxes”; “adding weight to boxes”; “overcharging customers more than the maximum allowable UPS retail rate”; and “charging customers for accessorial charges they did not request.”
According to the Hagans’ lawsuit, they claim that in the weeks and months following the San Diego meeting, no action was taken by TUPSS or UPS to investigate and stop the questionable practices and instead, the

Hagans became the target of retaliation and selective enforcement, which they believe ultimately destroyed their business. According to the Court documents, on February 5, 2014, UPS terminated the Hagans’ franchise agreements and directed them to cease operations at each of their eleven locations.
According to the Hagans’ attorneys Mark L. McKew and Stephen J. Savva, “good faith attempts to avoid litigation were exhausted with UPS’s counsel prior to filing the counterclaims and third-party action.” The

attorneys further state that “because this is a matter of public concern with the potential to impact a large number of consumers, a press conference will be scheduled shorty to share additional details about the evidence collected by investigators.” Consumers are encouraged to confirm pricing and delivery guarantees online, keep detailed records of all shipping transactions and promptly report cases of potential consumer fraud to the appropriate agencies.

For further information please contact Mark L. McKew, Esq. or Stephen J. Savva, Esq.

Also read:

THE UPS STORE Franchise Complaints

THE UPS STORE: Overview

THE UPS STORE Franchise Warning: It’s a Scam Claims Franchisee

Are THE UPS STORE / MAIL BOXES ETC. Franchise Owners Happy?

THE UPS STORE: How Much Do UPS Store Franchise Owners Make?

THE UPS STORE Franchise Owners Lose MBE Lawsuit

UPS STORE, MAIL BOXES ETC. Franchisees File Class Action Suit

 

ARE YOU FAMILIAR WITH THE UPS STORE FRANCHISE AND UPS STORE FRANCHISE OWNERS? ARE THEY CHEATING CUSTOMERS?  SHARE A COMMENT BELOW.

Contact UnhappyFranchisee.com

TAGS: The UPS Store, The UPS Store franchise, UPS franchise, UPS cheating, UPS rip-off, The UPS Store lawsuit, The UPS Store franchise lawsuit, The UPS Store complaints, The UPS Store problems, The UPS Store fraud, The UPS Store cheats, The UPS Store rip-off, The UPS Store scam, The UPS Store sucks, The UPS Store franchise complaints, Mark McKew, Stephen Savva, Robert Hagan, Thomas Hagan, UPS scandal

One thought on “Are THE UPS STORE Franchise Owners Cheating UPS Customers? Franchisee Lawsuit Says Yes.

  • July 24, 2016 at 11:48 pm
    Permalink

    Are the the Hagan brothers one is an artist from Austrailia?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *